In 2004, Eggert played the role of Ginger in the first edition of the TBS network's The Real Gilligan's Island reality show. She appeared on Scott Baio Is 45...and Single (featuring her Charles in Charge co-star) in 2007.
In August 2006, Baio was formally invited by the AIA Actors Studio to discuss his professional experiences in television and movies. He talked about his own acting career plus his recent forays into writing, directing and producing. In 2007, Baio starred in the successful VH1 celebrity reality series Scott Baio Is 45...and Single and its successor the following year, Scott Baio Is 46...and Pregnant. Baio was also the co-host of the VH1 reality show Confessions of a Teen Idol, in which former teen idols attempt to resurrect their careers.
Scott Baio Is 45...and Single is an American reality television show that aired on VH1 starring Scott Baio. The second season, entitled Scott Baio Is 46...and Pregnant, began on January 13, 2008.
On January 29, 2018, sexual misconduct allegations by Nicole Eggert resurfaced. She first made the allegations on the Nik Richie Radio show in 2013 and then repeated them on her Twitter account and Dr Oz Show. She claimed that the inappropriate relations started when she was 14 and that when she was 17, she had intercourse with him. Scott Baio has denied the allegations and called them complete lies. He said that he had had sexual relations with her only once, after she was 18, and provided evidence in the form of her own words to Nik Richie (that it happened "long after the show" finished filming, compared to the actual date production finished, which was 10 months after her 18th birthday). He uploaded video of her which he says shows her changing her story between 2013 and 2018.
Eggert has accused her former Charles In Charge co-star Scott Baio of sexually harassing and sexually abusing her as a minor, beginning at age 14. Baio has adamantly denied the claims. Baio has said that they engaged in a one-time consensual sexual encounter when Eggert was 18, which Eggert initiated. Eggert has said that she was 17, and that Baio initiated their encounter.